Hepatitis B vaccination of newborn infants in rural China: evaluation of a village-based, out-of-cold-chain delivery strategy
Lixia Wang a, Junhua Li b, Haiping Chen c, Fangjun Li b, Gregory L Armstrong d, Carib Nelson e, Wenyuan Ze c, Craig N Shapiro d
Globally, chronic cirrhosis and liver cancer caused by infection with hepatitis B virus (HBV) cause 600 000 deaths annually.1 Perinatal transmission (from mother to infant at birth) is a major route of transmission of HBV in areas such as Asia, where persistent infections are highly endemic (prevalence of hepatitis B surface antigen [HBsAg], > 8%) and the prevalence of hepatitis B e antigen (HBeAg, a serological marker that correlates with an increased risk of transmission) is high among chronically infected mothers.1–3 Vaccination against HBV is approximately 90% effective in preventing perinatal transmission when the first dose (“birth dose”) of vaccine is given within 24 hours after birth.2 WHO recommends this practice in countries with substantial perinatal transmission.2
Giving hepatitis B (HepB) vaccine within 24 hours after birth to infants born in remote areas, especially to those born at home, can be difficult logistically owing to the lack of cold-chain infrastructure. Although China recommends that the first dose of HepB vaccine be given at birth, followed by the second and third doses at age 1 and 6 months, the timely administration (within 24 hours after birth) of the birth dose is low. Results from a nationwide survey carried out in 1999 showed that among children who had received a first dose of HepB vaccine, only 39% received it within 24 hours after birth.4 Among children born at home – who represent at least 17% of the birth cohort, or 2.3 million children annually – timely administration among those who had received a first dose was even lower (17%).4,5 A national serological survey in 2002 showed that HBsAg prevalence was 5% among children overall and was especially high among children in rural areas (8%).6
As a strategy to improve coverage of the HepB vaccine birth dose, WHO recommends the use of vaccine vial monitors (VVMs) – heat-sensitive labels that change colour with cumulative exposure to excessive heat – in combination with proper training of vaccine providers; HepB vaccine can be stored without refrigeration when labelled with VVMs.7,8 HepB vaccine maintains its potency for 1–3 months at temperatures up to 37 °C and can be safely stored outside the cold chain in tropical climates.9–12 Indonesia has successfully introduced an out-of-cold-chain strategy for delivery of the HepB vaccine birth dose nationwide, storing vaccine in the homes of village midwives to make the vaccine more readily available for home births.12 Although the strategy is highly promising, its departure from standard cold-chain practices and concerns about the logistics of home-based immunization have limited its introduction in other countries.13
Our study explored the feasibility and effectiveness of a village-based, out-of-cold-chain strategy for improving timely administration of the HepB vaccine birth dose in rural areas of Hunan Province, China. We further explored the use of a prefilled injection device (Uniject) to administer HepB vaccine in villages outside the cold chain.
The recombinant HepB vaccine used in the study was produced by Beijing Tiantan Biological Products, Beijing, and was supplied either in single-dose ampoules or in Uniject devices, both of which were filled in China. All vaccine was provided with VVMs attached either to the ampoule or to the Uniject packaging. The study design allowed vaccines to be kept outside the cold chain until the VVM indicated that they should be discarded, but for a maximum duration of 1 month.
In the study areas, either auto-disable syringes or Uniject devices were used to administer vaccine. Uniject is a prefilled, single-dose injection device developed by the Program for Appropriate Technology in Health (PATH) and licensed to Becton & Dickinson for commercial production and distribution. The device is compact, self-contained and non-reusable, comprising a hypodermic needle attached to a small plastic blister prefilled with a single dose of vaccine.
Study sites and dates
The study was carried out in Hunan Province between September 2003 and September 2004. Within the province, three counties – Sangzhi, Longshan and Fenghuang – were chosen based on high proportions (40–60%) of out-of-hospital births. In all three counties, as in the rest of China, HepB vaccination is recommended for all children from birth. Within the three counties, all townships situated at least 20 km from the county capital (81 of 116 townships in the county) were chosen to participate in the study. The participating townships included 957 villages, with a total population of about 800 000.
During the study period, 6988 infants were born in the three study groups. In the baseline coverage survey, there were 1202 infants, with 42.4% born at home. In the follow-up coverage survey, there were also 1202 infants, 38.5% born at home. In the serological survey, there were 606 infants.
Rural townships (those lying more than 20 km from the county capital) in the participating counties were randomly divided into three groups:Group 1 (ampoule inside the cold chain): HepB vaccine used was provided in ampoules, stored within the cold chain and administered using auto-disable syringes to infants in township hospitals. HepB vaccination practices in these townships differed from pre-study practices only in that there was additional awareness-raising about the importance of vaccination. Parents of children born outside the hospital were requested by village doctors to bring their children to the hospital as soon after birth as possible for the first dose of HepB vaccine; Group 2 (ampoule outside the cold chain): HepB vaccine was provided in ampoules, stored out of the cold chain in villages, and administered using auto-disable syringes by village-based health workers to infants in their homes; Group 3 (HepB-Uniject outside the cold chain): HepB vaccine was provided in Uniject devices, stored out of the cold chain in villages and administered by village-based health workers to infants in their homes.In groups 2 and 3, infants born in the hospital received the birth dose at the hospital using vaccine stored in the cold chain, and infants born at home received vaccine stored outside the cold chain at ambient temperature at the provider’s home or clinic in a box protected from direct sunlight, freezing, extreme heat sources and tampering. In all groups, the second and third doses of HepB vaccine were stored and delivered according to group assignment, i.e. inside the cold chain (group 1) or outside the cold chain (groups 2 and 3).
At the beginning of the study, investigators met with public health officials at all levels, including township health-care workers, village doctors and midwives. In addition, residents of all three counties were informed of the study by a variety of means, including public service announcements in print and broadcast media. Information provided included an explanation of the importance of HepB immunization and of the birth dose.
In each study group within each county, one immunization clinic was randomly selected to monitor vaccine temperature. Gemini TinyTalk Data Loggers, which are electronic temperature-data recorders, were stored with the study vaccines to monitor storage temperatures.
Evaluation of impact
Two surveys were conducted, one before study implementation (the “baseline coverage survey”) and one after (the “follow-up coverage survey”), to evaluate the impact of the interventions on timely administration of the birth dose of HB vaccine. For both surveys, a modification of the WHO immunization cluster survey was used.14 In each of the three study groups, 40 villages (clusters) were randomly chosen with probability proportional to size. At each selected village, the survey team started at the village centre and continued in a randomly chosen direction until it had identified and interviewed the parents of at least 10 children aged 9–20 months for the baseline survey and aged 1–11 months for the follow-up survey (which focused on birth dose and was conducted immediately after the intervention). Interviewers enquired about receipt of immunizations and reasons for any delay in receiving the birth dose of HepB vaccine. Interviewers also reviewed immunization cards kept by parents and immunization records at the offices of village and township health workers.
Evaluation of immunological response
In a separate survey to compare antibody responses to the vaccine (the serological survey), approximately 200 children from each group (12.8%, 11.4% and 10.7% of the total number of children vaccinated during the study in groups 1, 2 and 3, respectively) were selected at random at the end of the study to give blood specimens. Eligibility was restricted to children aged 7–11 months who had received all three doses of the HB vaccine including a birth dose (defined as a dose administered within 24 hours of birth) and who had received the last dose at least a month before the survey.
All serum specimens were tested by radioimmunoassay (provided by the Bei Fang Biological Technical Institute, Beijing) at the National Vaccine and Serum Institute (NVSI) for HBsAg, antibody to HBsAg (anti-HBs), and antibody to HBV core antigen (anti-HBc). For samples with undetectable titres, a value of 2.0 mIU/ml (the lower limit of detection of the assay) was assigned when calculating the geometric mean titre. The anti-HBs titres were estimated by serial dilution.
For all analyses, timely receipt of the birth dose was defined as receipt of the first dose of HB vaccine within 24 hours of birth. The baseline and follow-up surveys were analysed with CSAMPLE (US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) and SUDAAN (RTI International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA), which take into account the clustered sampling used in these surveys. Proportions were compared by the chi-squared test as implemented in SUDAAN. All other analyses were performed with SAS (RTI International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA). The baseline and follow-up surveys were powered to be likely to detect an improvement of 15% in birth-dose coverage if the coverage were 75% in the non-intervention group, assuming a design effect of 1.5. The serological survey was powered to detect a decline of 10% in the seroprotection rate if the baseline rate were 95%.
Study monitoring and ethical review
The study was carried out by NVSI and the Hunan Provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention with funding from PATH and technical assistance from PATH and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Ethical review committees at NVSI, PATH, and CDC reviewed and approved the protocol before the start of the study. All families of the infants included gave written informed consent to participate in the study.
Timely administration of birth dose
Coverage of the birth dose of HepB vaccine administered on time increased in all three groups: from 8.0% to 57.9% in group 1 (ampoule inside the cold chain), from 11.3% to 67.8% in group 2 (ampoule outside the cold chain), and from 6.8% to 77.3% in group 3 (HepB-Uniject outside the cold chain), with P < 0.05 for differences between each of the groups (P = 0.043 for group 1 versus group 2, P = 0.042 for group 2 versus group 3, P < 0.001 for group 1 versus group 3) (Table 1).
Among infants born in a hospital, birth-dose vaccine coverage increased from 13.4% (95% confidence interval, CI, 10.4–16.4%) to 81.9% (95% CI, 78.3–85.5%; Fig. 1). Birth-dose coverage was higher in group 3 (87.6%; 95% CI, 82.0–93.2%) than in group 1 (77.9%; 95% CI, 71.4–84.3%) but group 2 (80.3%; 95% CI, 74.9–85.7%) was not significantly different from the other two groups (Fig. 1).
Among infants born at home, birth-dose coverage also increased in all three groups, especially in the out-of-cold-chain groups. Birth-dose coverage was higher in group 2 (51.8%; 95% CI, 40.9–62.7%) and group 3 (66.7%; 95% CI, 56.9–76.5%) than in group 1 (25.2%; 95% CI, 14.6–35.7%; P < 0.001 for both comparisons; Fig. 1).
For infants born at home among all groups, birth-dose coverage was higher for those vaccinated at home than those who were taken by parents to township hospitals for vaccination (73.5% versus 32.8%; P < 0.001).
A sample of parents was asked why their children had not been vaccinated within 24 hours after birth. Before the study, 78% of parents said the main reason was that they had not been informed by a health-care provider about the importance of receiving HepB vaccine within 24 hours after birth. After the study, the proportion giving this response decreased to 41% (Table 2). For children born at home, the second most common reason was “residence too far from the immunization clinics” (11% before the study and 19% after the study).
Table 1. Improvements in timely delivery of the hepatitis B vaccine at birth, by study group, Hunan, China
Table 2. Reasons given by parents for late administration of hepatitis B vaccine at birth to children born at home or in hospital, Hunan, China
Results of the serological survey
Of the 606 children in the serological survey, all of whom had received three doses of HepB vaccine including a birth dose, 580 (96%) had detectable levels of anti-HBs and 89% had levels of ⩾10 mIU/ml (“protective levels”). There were no significant differences between groups in the proportion of infants with seroprotective levels (group 1, 89%; group 2, 91%; group 3, 89%) or in the geometric mean titres of anti-HBs (group 1, 95.5 mIU/ml; group 2, 93.3 mIU/ml; group 3, 102.3 mIU/ml). Of all children in the serological survey, 5 (0.8%) were HBsAg-positive and anti-HBc positive (group 1, 0.5%; group 2, 0.5%; group 3, 1.5%; P = 0.43 for differences between groups).
Monitoring vaccine storage and adverse events
Two of the three township refrigerators monitored in the group 1 sites showed temperatures of less than 0 °C. In one refrigerator, the temperature was less than 0 °C for about 4 months. Upon leaving the township hospital, vaccine in townships in groups 2 and 3 was exposed to temperatures ranging from 2 °C to 30 °C, with an average out-of-cold-chain storage temperature of 16 °C. Of 15 000 doses distributed outside the cold chain, 50 doses from different villages in groups 2 and 3 had to be discarded owing to VVM colour changes indicative of excessive heat exposure.
Serious adverse events following administration of HepB vaccine were monitored using China’s routine passive monitoring system; none were reported during the study.
The high risk of transmission of HBV from an infected mother to her newborn infant and the serious long-term consequences of perinatal HBV infection (e.g. cirrhosis or liver cancer) make prevention of transmission through immunization at birth particularly important.15 In remote areas in China and other countries where many children are born at home, timely (within 24 hours) administration of HepB vaccine has been difficult to achieve using routine methods of immunization delivery. This study showed that timely administration of the first dose of HepB vaccine to newborns can be substantially improved through public awareness efforts and provider training and, especially for infants born at home, through storage of vaccine in villages outside the cold chain and administration of vaccine by village health workers.
Expanding the role of existing village-based health workers is an effective way to improve access to immunization for hard-to-reach populations. While the trend in China has been towards encouraging births and HepB birth-dose immunization in hospitals, this study validated an alternate strategy for areas where it is not feasible for women to give birth in hospitals. For infants born at home, home-based immunization by village health workers resulted in substantially higher rates of timely administration of the first HepB vaccine dose compared with immunization at township hospitals. Storing the vaccine out of the cold chain in the village health workers’ homes or clinics is a simple and feasible approach to enable village-based immunization in areas where refrigeration is not reliable. In addition, according to local custom in some minority areas, newborn infants cannot be taken out of the home during the first month after birth. At-home immunization is the only way to deliver the first HepB vaccine dose on time among these populations. This study confirmed the findings of other studies in Viet Nam, Indonesia and China that have shown that HepB vaccine is stable when used outside the cold chain.7,8,16
The most common concerns about taking vaccines out of the cold chain and hospital infrastructure – temperature exposure and injection safety – were not found to be problems in this study. In fact, the results of temperature monitoring show that storing vaccine within the cold chain may be problematic if, as observed here, the vaccine is subjected to freezing in cold-chain refrigerators. Although HepB vaccine is relatively heat-tolerant, it dissociates from its adjuvant and may lose immunogenicity if frozen.17 Several studies in other countries have shown that vaccines are often exposed to freezing temperatures in the cold chain.18–20 Taking vaccine out of the cold chain could potentially decrease the risk of vaccine damage caused by inadvertent freezing. However, in cold climates, vaccines stored out of the cold chain would need to be protected from freezing during winter months, and a repeat study in a cold climate may be warranted to evaluate the risks of vaccine freezing outside the cold chain.
Even among infants born in areas where vaccine was not stored outside the cold chain (group 1), timely administration of HepB vaccine increased substantially for infants born at home and for those born in hospitals, despite the absence of interventions other than raising awareness through provider training and supervision. This finding underscores the importance of ongoing monitoring and programme support in optimizing the results of new programmes such as the introduction of the HepB vaccine birth dose. The follow-up coverage survey revealed that some health workers were reluctant to give the vaccine birth dose to infants perceived to be sick, weak or of low birth weight, further underscoring the need for monitoring of hospital staff to ensure that all infants born in hospitals receive the HepB vaccine birth dose on time.
This village-based, out-of-cold-chain strategy is relevant to the global reduction of HBV infection, since WHO estimates that more than 50% of the world’s children are born at home.1 This strategy could be applied in many countries where health workers live among populations that are not accessible by the formal health system. It could be beneficial not only in geographically isolated areas, but also in urban areas where cultural differences impede access to clinic-based immunizations. ■
- ST Goldstein, FJ Zhou, SC Hadler, BP Bell, EE Mast, HS Margolis. A mathematical model to estimate global hepatitis B disease burden and vaccination impact. Int J Epidemiol 2005; 34: 1329-39.
- WHO position on hepatitis B vaccine. Wkly Epidemiol Rec 2004; 79: 255-63.
- World Health Organization Department of Vaccines and Biologicals. Introduction of hepatitis B vaccine into childhood immunization services (WHO/V&B/01/31). Geneva: WHO; 2001.
- Zhu X, Zhang X, Wang L, Shapiro CN, Wang KY. Status of hepatitis B vaccination in China: results from the 1999 National Coverage Study. In: Margolis HS, Alter MJ, Liang TJ, Dienstag JL, eds. Viral hepatitis and liver disease. Atlanta: International Medical Press; 2002:254–257.
- China Health Statistics Yearbook. Beijing: China Union Medical University Press; 2005:194.
- Yuansheng Chen. 2002 National Nutrition Survey. Beijing: Chinese Center for Disease Control; 2006.
- World Health Organization Department of Vaccines and Biologicals. Getting started with vaccine vial monitors (WHO/V&B/02.35). Geneva: WHO; 2002.
- DB Hipgrave, JE Maynard, BA Biggs. Improving birth dose coverage of hepatitis B vaccine. Bull World Health Organ 2006; 84: 65-71.
- Galazka A, Milstien J, Zaffran M. Thermostability of vaccines (WHO/GPV98.07). Geneva: WHO; 1998.
- BF Otto, IM Suarnawa, T Stewart, C Nelson, TA Ruff, A Widjaya, et al., et al. At-birth immunisation against hepatitis B using a novel pre-filled immunisation device stored outside the cold chain. Vaccine 1999; 18: 498-502.
- DB Hipgrave, TN Tran, VM Huong, DT Dat, NT Nga, HT Long, et al., et al. Immunogenicity of a locally produced hepatitis B vaccine with the birth dose stored outside the cold chain in rural Vietnam. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2006; 74: 255-60.
- A Sutanto, IM Suarnawa, CM Nelson, T Stewart, TI Soewarso. Home delivery of heat-stable vaccines in Indonesia: outreach immunization with a prefilled, single-use injection device. Bull World Health Organ 1999; 77: 119-26.
- Letarte C, Mallins P. Meeting minutes, TechNet meeting, March 23–25, 2004, Antalya, Turkey. Geneva: WHO TechNet Secretariat; 2004.
- RH Henderson, T Sundaresan. Cluster sampling to assess immunization coverage: a review of experience with a simplified sampling method. Bull World Health Organ 1982; 60: 253-60.
- SA Marion, M Tomm Pastore, DW Pi, RG Mathias. Long-term follow-up of hepatitis B vaccine in infants of carrier mothers. Am J Epidemiol 1994; 140: 734-46.
- Hepatitis B vaccine delivery outside the cold chain: the Long An County, China. Example. Global Perspectives on Hepatitis. 1991; 2: 3-4.
- D Diminsky, N Moav, M Gorecki, Y Barenholz. Physical, chemical and immunological stability of CHO-derived hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) particles. Vaccine 1999; 18: 3-17.
- CM Nelson, H Wibisono, H Purwanto, I Mansyur, V Moniaga, A Widjaya, et al., et al. Hepatitis B vaccine freezing in the Indonesian cold chain: evidence and solutions. Bull World Health Organ 2004; 82: 99-105.
- K Hanjeet, MS Lye, M Sinniah, A Schnur. Evaluation of cold chain monitoring in the Kelantan, Malaysia. Bull World Health Organ 1996; 74: 391-7.
- NC Miller, MF Harris. Are childhood immunization programs in Australia at risk? Investigation of the cold chain in the Northern Territory. Bull World Health Organ 1994; 72: 401-8.
- Program for Appropriate Technology in Health, Beijing Office, China. Current address: Environment, Science, Technology and Health Section, United States Embassy, 3 Xiu Shui Bei Jie, Jian Guo Men Wai, Chao Yang District, Beijing 100600, China.
- Hunan Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Hunan, China.
- National Vaccine and Serum Institute, Beijing, China.
- Division of Viral Hepatitis, National Center for Infectious Diseases, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
- Program for Appropriate Technology in Health, Seattle, Washington, USA.